Thursday, 22 September 2011

Bell rates... Oktoberfest 2011

event: Munich Oktoberfest
place: Theresienwiese, Munich, Germany
date: Sep 17 – Oct 3

The biggest beer festival in the world, Oktoberfest has been held almost every year since 1810 - only missing 24 years out of 201. We attended on Saturday 17th September and Sunday 18th, and had an excellent time on both occasions.

Having attended last year as well, I knew what to expect; great atmosphere, great beer (at high prices) and extreme difficulty in finding a seat unless you have a reservation.

The 'finding a seat' part is quite important, as you're unlikely to be served unless you're at a table. Last year we tried about four tents and their accompanying biergartens before we managed to squeeze in with some Dutch guys. This year, on the saturday, we managed to get into a tent in a closed-off section, which required a €3 entry fee (must have put a few tourists off as it was much quieter and we got a table no problem). €3 is quite reasonable, considering a table reservation has to be made well in advance and costs around €30. Beer served there was Augustiner, in proper stoneware steins, for an added authentic traditional element. Sadly, no tasting notes, and no individual review, as I lost my phone, so had no method of recording any details of the beer, and my memory was impaired by drinking strong Bavarian Lager by the litre.

Second day, Sunday, was very wet, and this seemed to put people off even more than an entrance fee, meaning the biergartens were all pretty much empty. We managed to get a table in the Winzerer Fähndl biergarten, serving Paulaner. Again, no tasting notes, but it went down well. Moved inside later, and enjoyed the band, who's ecclectic playlist included hits by Lynyrd Skynyrd and The Proclaimers.

Overall, the beer is great, and the atmosphere is great too. I'd recommend Oktoberfest to anyone who likes beer and a good time. make sure to take plenty of cash though, as a Maß (1 litre glass of beer) costs the best part of €10.

I'd also like to send my warmest regards to anyone I met, and also my apologies to them, as I no doubt rambled on and talked a load of pish. If you were there, I was the beard with an idiot attached, wearing a yellow Scotland shirt with 'Bell' and the number 76 on the back.

Especial shout out to Christine and her husband from Virginia, USA. Please send me some of your homebrew and I'll review it.

And so, onto the scores - this being an event and not an individual beer, it doesn't get the SCT rating, but instead an AVB... not to be confused with Alcohol By Volume, of course.

Atmosphere: Fantastic. Met people from all over the world, all of them out to have a good time. 4/4
Value: a Maß seems fairly expensive... and it is. But when you look at the volume of beer you're actually getting for the money, it equates to roughly £4.75 a pint, which isn't too unreasonable for a high-quality beer brewed specially for the festival. 3/4
Booze: Oktoberfest beers are generally Märzen lagers, brewed specifically for the Festival, although Weizens, wines and shots are available if you know where to look, so all bases covered. Beers generally excellent. 4/4

Overall: I'll be back next year, hopefully, and I'd encourage anyone to visit. 11/12




Wednesday, 7 September 2011

Bell rates... Guinness Original

type: Stout
origin: Ireland
ABV: 4.2%
location: house
served: 330ml bottle to a glass


There is some debate whether Guinness is a stout or a porter, and my good friend and mentor Mr AG McGhee BSc (Hons) insists that it is in fact a porter. Now, he's the biggest beer snob I know, and quite knowledgeable about alcoholic drinks made from fermented sugars... however it says 'Stout' on the label, so I'll rate it as such.

It should also be noted that the label on the back of this bottle also says 'Brewed in Dublin', which is important as the water used to brew the beer is one of the most important factors. Guinness brewed outside of Dublin is like the Irish football squad at the 1994 World Cup. Or one of those fake Irish theme pubs. It's just not the real thing.

This is though. Good body, good aftertaste, good aroma, great looks.


Smell: roasted barley and hops coming through nicely. inviting. 3/4

Colour: black, with the creamy-white head. It's iconic, and it gets a full 4/4

Taste: a pleasant variety of warm, dry, chocolatey, roast flavours. good level of hops and bitterness, good aftertaste. 3/4

Overall: superior to the foreign stuff. 10/12

Friday, 19 August 2011

Bell Rates... Mountain Dew & Gin

type: mixed drink

ingredients:
25ml Gin (Gordon's, 37.5% ABV)
Mountain Dew (79mg Caffeine)
Ice

Mountain Dew, by itself, has a greeny-yellow colour, and just a slight lemon & lime smell. Taste-wise it's fairly standard, with little impact on the tastebuds, and little aftertaste. not overly sweet, but drinkable, and provides the caffeine boost that can fuel havoc quite effectively.

Mixed with Gin, and it actually improves. The edge is removed from the Gin, and the whole thing becomes a more sophisticated way to get the energy of a Jägerbomb or Vodka & Red Bull, but you can take your time.

A good friend of mine swears by Gin as a way to clear the head somewhat after at the three-quarters stage of a night out, and he's got a point; Gin provides some of the effects of sobriety, but none of the downsides. 1

Smell: light, fresh citrus, but not much of it. 2/4
Colour: greeny-yellow. clean looking, not too obvious 2/4
Taste: clean, fresh taste. very easy to drink. a little bit of sharpness, alcohol of the Gin only evident in the aftertaste. 3/4

overall: an energy-restoring Lemonade & Gin alternative, that won't make you go insane and climb on top of bus shelters2. 9/12


1. not actual sobriety, but you can probably walk a bit straighter, and while it won't actually stop you talking pish, you'll now realise you're talking pish, and may react appropriately to this revelation by yourself.
2. hopefully.

Thursday, 11 August 2011

Bell Rates... Ben Nevis

type: IPA
origin: Scotland
ABV: 4%
location: house
served: 330ml bottle to a glass

Another offering from Traditional Scottish Ales, Ben Nevis is a 'Ruby Red', and shows TSA's usual characteristics of being a fairly unique, Scottish organic beer.

For an IPA, it's not overly hopped, and not overly bitter either. It is very malty though, and actually reminds me somewhat of a Porter, but with a bit more of an IPA's sharpness.


Smell: not very strong, but the malt comes though well. 2/4

Colour: a fantastic rich reddish-brown mahogany colour. 4/4

Taste: a chocolatey, malty taste, but quite fresh. A little bit on the this side though. 3/4

overall: taste-wise there's a bit of a cross-over going on, it seems, but it works well. Great colour. 9/12


see also: Bell rates... Glencoe


more info: www.traditionalscottishales.co.uk

Friday, 22 July 2011

Bell Rates... Ladzbräu 'Weizenlager' homebrew

type: lager
origin: my house, Scotland
ABV: ?
location: Biergarten
served: wine bottle to glass

Brewing your own beer at home can be a risky business - not so much the risk of something blowing up, but more the risk that you've spent a fair sum of money and waited several months just to end up with foul-tasting slop. Especially if you just make up a recipe instead of following an established one. It's a fun and challenging hobby, but there are so many unknowns when starting out, or trying something new, that the danger of making 12 litres of undrinkable beer can be quite daunting.

It was with a mixture of hope and optimism, therefore, that we opened the first bottle of 'Experimental Brew 1' last week.

My co-conspirator, Mr AG McGhee BSc (Hons), did the honours. No pun intended.

The recipe was initially aimed towards a Pilsner-type Lager, but did include wheat. I can't remember exactly why. The wheat did impart a lot of Weissbier characteristics - the most immediately evident of these being the cloudy look. Due to 'Experimental Brew 1' being a pretty rubbish moniker, it was renamed 'Weizenlager'.




The smell, I'm pleased to report was excellent. A good start. The colour is quite pleasing as well, with the lager malts imparting a warm yellow colouring to the hazy, weissbier look. The taste, again is a mix of a wheaty ale and a lager.

I may be biased... actually, I am biased, but I'm extremely pleased with the final product. The recipe could be refined, and it can definitely be improved, but it's a great start, I feel.

On the down side, head retention is quite poor, and it does go flat quite quickly, so a shade more carbonation would be welcome. Of course, drink it quickly and this problem doesn't enter the equation!

Which brings me neatly on to the alcohol content. At this stage it's a complete unknown, as we forgot to measure the gravity prior to fermentation, so we can't calculate it. I'd guess it's around 5 or 6% ABV, but that's purely a guess. There's no taste of alcohol, but you do feel it.

Smell: Sweet, with citrus notes, and a good level of hoppiness. 4/4

Colour: A hazy, warm, mustard yellow. like sunshine in a glass. 3/4

Taste: good body, with a very clean finish and an intricate aftertaste. Good level of hops. Sweet banana and citrus flavours balance the bitterness well. Wheaty. Only the lack of carbonation (and resulting lack of head retention) lets it down. 3/4

Overall: room for improvement, but I'm well chuffed. 10/12

Tuesday, 28 June 2011

Bell Rates... Stella Artois Cidre

type: Cider
origin: Belgium
ABV: 4.5%
location: Biergarten
served: 568ml bottle to a glass, over ice



"C'est Cidre, not Cider" the billboards claim, as the makers of Stella Artois try to convince us that their new product somehow transcends mere fermented apples, and is actually some sort of high-class, luxury drink that is the toast of Belgian high-society.

I'm not convinced.

It's a served-over-ice cider, and call me cynical all you like, but it's going to fit into the same bracket as Magners, Bulmers and Kopparberg. It's InBv's latest attempt at plugging a hole in their all-encompassing market strategy. It's a great BBQ cider, ideal for a lazy summer's evening, but it's not a Martini, or a fine bottle of Beaujolais... whatever that is.

It's cider. People in pubs will order it as such:
"Bottle of Stella cider please."
"Want a glass with ice with that?"
"Aye, please."
is how it's mainly going to play out.


That said, it does look good in a beer garden. The bottle is a fairly classy design, with a chunky, high-quality look, and a gold label that complements the colour of the cider well. Once poured (over ice) you get a refreshing, easy to drink pint, politely described as 'rounded'.

It's a cider that 'non-cider-drinkers' could probably drink quite easily. There's very little taste of alcohol, and very little aftertaste. There is a little bit of apple in there, but you need to be looking for it. It's not unpleasant by any means, but it's clear that InBev aimed directly for Magners with this one, and only missed the mark by a short way.

Smell: There's nothing bad to say about the aroma, but most of that has to come down to the fact that it hardly smells of anything. 2/4

Colour: A very Magners-like pale orange, but just a little bit paler, in my estimation - outdoing their Irish rivals in getting their watered-down Irn-Bru tone one step lighter than Magners itself. 2/4

Taste: Less sweet than Magners, with less aftertaste and less prominent flavours. Slightly acidic, but overall very drinkable due to its inoffensive nature. 2/4

Overall: Not bad, but not Magners. Slightly less of all the important bits (or at least the bits I use for ratings, anyway) and slightly more of the premium branding. 6/12


The 'Stella Artois' part of the name becomes clear when you consider all of this, as this really is the cider equivalent of Stella Artois Lager. It's got the same sort of characteristics as its namesake - generic, commercial, mass-produced - and will probably sell just as well. The marketing strategy might as well have been "Reassuringly Expensive" again... or just "More Expensive than Magner's" since everything else about Stella Cidre seems to have been developed using that as a yardstick.

It's disappointing that InBev just rolled out a generic cider, with no real uniqueness to it, stuck a familiar brand label on it and were satisfied with that. They could have created something new, launched a genuinely new product, with a genuinely new brand identity, but they weren't feeling adventurous enough.

The Premium over-ice cider market has a few 'big-guns', and Stella Cidre is a 9mm with '.44 Magnum' stamped on the side.


more info: http://www.stellaartois.com/cidre/

Saturday, 21 May 2011

Bell Rates... Glencoe

type: Stout
origin: Scotland
ABV: 4.5%
location: house
served: 330ml bottle to a glass

Glencoe Organic Wild Oat Stout, to give the beer its full name, is produced by Traditional Scottish Ales near Alloa (it says Stirling on the bottle, but it's marginally closer to Alloa) and while the naming it after a part of the highlands is a slight example of geographic poetic license, at least the Alloa link gives them plenty of permit to the 'Traditional Scottish' part. Alloa was once one of the most prominent brewing towns in the British Isles, due to the high quality of the local barley and water - something that Glencoe Stout can draw upon to this day, but sadly, most of the breweries are now defunct or consumed by big-business corporations.

This isn't one of those corporate beer-by-numbers efforts though, and is clearly an independent operation, evidenced by the strong emphasis on 'organic' beer. While this label might attract people who read the Guardian, and concern themselves over whether the lentils in their soup were free-range or not, the important bit is this attention to organic ingredients results in a clean, light taste. Chocolate and roasted malt elements abound.


Smell: quite strong, but balanced, and just the good bits. 3/4

Colour: a dark caramel, inviting and warm 3/4

Taste: malty, quite sweet and with just a little bit of bitterness. Very smooth, very balanced and very clean - especially in the aftertaste. 3/4

overall: a good traditional Scottish-style stout; smooth, warm and flavoursome. 9/12



more info: www.traditionalscottishales.co.uk

Friday, 6 May 2011

Bell Rates... Bulmers Red Apple

type: cider
origin: England
ABV: 4.5%
location: house
served: 568ml bottle to glass, over ice


Right, to clarify who makes this product, it's HP Bulmer of England not Magners of Clonmel, Ireland. That might seem obvious to you, but in Ireland Magners is sold under the 'Bulmers' label, despite not having had anything to do with HP Bulmer for many years.

Outside Ireland, of course, the difference is obvious.

Anyroad, this is their 'Red Apple' limited edition cider, introduced at the tail end of 2010, and is an attempt by Bulmers to carve out every niche-within-a-niche they can. But who can blame them? The 'over ice' cider market has boomed in the last decade and it's Magners who've got the best market position.

Red Apple is a subtly different version of Bulmers' main product - which is clearly what they set out to achieve, so mission accomplished there. As the name suggests, the cider is brewed using red apples, and while some ciders don't have a lot of 'apple' taste left after the yeast is finished transforming all that juice to alcohol, this one does taste of apples, and red ones at that.

It's also very refreshing, which is the other must for this type of product.

Smell: apples! but quite faint and I think they've missed a trick by not going for the heavy-apple smell to reinforce the 'apple' label a bit more 2/4

Colour: again, I'd have preferred a more red colour - it's supposed to be a 'limited edition', so why not make it a bit more distinctive looking? 2/4

Taste: this is where it pulls the points back - refreshing, sharp, not overly sweet and with a definite red apple flavour. 3/4

overall: tastes just different enough to stand out from the crowd without being a 'speciality' taste that will alienate less adventurous drinkers, but not adventurous enough to carve out a new niche in an already crowded market. 7/12




Saturday, 23 April 2011

Bell Rates... Sierra Nevada Pale Ale

type: Pale Ale
origin: California, USA
ABV: 5.6%
location: house
served: 350ml bottle to glass


In recent years American craft breweries have seen a growth in sales, and it has to be said that some of the most interesting and high-quality American beers are brewed in small batches by people who's focus is on quality, rather than on shareholders and Superbowl commercials.

Sierra Nevada Brewing Co. is one of these craft breweries, and although they've expanded somewhat over the last 30 years, and their products are now sold all over the world, the beer is still brewed with the same ideals of quality.

It should be noted that this is an American Pale Ale, and thus differs somewhat from a British PA, due to the different hop varieties in use on the other side of the pond. My own feeling is that Sierra Nevada's effort isn't actually too far off a lager, possessed as it is of a rather sharp, almost acerbic taste, and while it's very hoppy, it's not overly bitter. The beer also has a complex range of fruity and flowery undertones and a herbal element that (after going through all the herbs in my spice rack one-by-one) i'd say wasn't far off thyme.

Smell: not very strong, and with only hints of the complex flavour coming through in the bouquet. A little bit of citrus.  2/4

Colour: an attractive rich amber.  3/4

Taste: complex, and very hoppy, but clean and not too bitter.  3/4

overall: an interesting beer - and while 'interesting' could be considered to be good or bad, this definitely sits on the side of 'good' interesting. A quality brew that proves that America can produce high-quality beer when they realise that good beer is a result of dedication and fine ingredients, and not a result of board meetings and advertising budgets.   8/12



Bell Rates... Fuller's London Pride

type: Ale
origin: England
ABV: 4.7%
location: house
served: 500ml bottle to glass

Cor blimey guvnah, A pint of bitter and a plate of jellied eels please.

Actually... forget the jellied eels, i'll just have the beer.

And quite a good beer it is too. A premium ale from one of Britain's biggest independent brewers, London Pride ticks all the boxes for presentation, and comes across as being a quality product.

'Bitter' is obviously meant to be just that, but there's a line that has to be drawn before the point when a beer becomes too bitter to drink comfortably. Thankfully, Fuller's have kept London Pride's bitterness at a level that provides a good balance between strong flavour and ease of drinking.

Smell: Malty, but not too strong. Fairly balanced. 2/4

Colour: honey, copper. Warm and inviting. 3/4

Taste: Malty, light, smooth bitter, with hops becoming more evident in the aftertaste. 3/4

overall: a smooth, drinkable beer, with a good bit of character. 8/12